Taking the Enemy as Medicine: Dialectic and Therapy in the Work of Two Early Indian Doxographers

Document Type: Research Paper


Munich Graduate School for Ancient Studies, Institut für Indologie und Tibetologie, Ludwig-Maximilians Universität


This article discusses the function of dialectic in religious history, focusing on the works of two major sixth century Indian intellectuals and doxographers Bhāviveka and Haribhadra Sūri, who belonged to the competing Madhyamaka Buddhist and Jaina traditions respectively. The article studies how these two figures used medical metaphors for their dialectic purposes.


Baltussen, Han. 2005. "The Presocratics in the Doxographical Tradition. Sources, Controversies, and Current Research." Studia Humaniora Tartuensia 6.A.6: 1-26.

Chapple, Christopher Key. 2003. Reconciling Yogas, Haribhadra's Collection of Views on Yoga, with a New Translation of Haribhadra's Yogadṛṣṭisamuccaya by Christopher Key Chappel and John Thomas Casey.  Albany: State University of New York Press.

Eckel, Malcolm David. 2008. Bhāviveka and His Buddhist Opponents. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Fuller, Paul. 2005. The Notion of Diṭṭhi in Theravāda Buddhism: The Point of View. Oxon: RoutledgeCurzon.

Halbfass, Wilhem. 1988. India and Europe: An Essay in Understanding.  New York: State University of New York Press.

Hsu, Chien Y. 2013. Bhāviveka’s Jewel in the Hand Treatise: Elucidating a Path to Awakening Utilizing Formal Inference. University of Calgary.

Laks, André. 2007. Histoire, Doxographie, Vérité, Études Sur Aristote, Théophraste Et La Philosophie Présocratique. Louvain-la-Neuve: Éditions Peeters.

Mansfeld, J., and D.T. Runia. 1997. Aëtiana. 1. The Sources.  Oxford: E. J. Brill.

Nicholson, A. J. 2010. Unifying Hinduism: Philosophy and Identity in Indian Intellectual History.  New York: Columbia University Press.

Nussbaum, Martha Craven. 1994. The Therapy of Desire, Theory and Practice in Hellenistic Ethics. Vol. 2. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton Universiyt Press.

Qvarnström, Olle. 1999. "Haribhadra and the Beginnings of Doxography in India." In Approaches to Jaina Studies: Philosophy, Logic, Rituals and Symbols, edited by N. K. Wagle and Olle Qvarnström, 169-210. Toronto: Center for South Asian Studies.

Shukla, R.S. 1989. India as Known to Haribhadra Suri.  Meerut: Kusumanjali Prakashan.

Tatia, Nathmal. 1951. Studies in Jaina Philosophy. Varanasi P.V.Research Institute, Jainashram, Hindu University.

Watanabe, Chikafumi. 1994. Bhā-Viveka (A.D. C. 490-570)’S Madhyamaka-Hṛdaya-Kārikā, Tattvajñānaisanā, Verses 137-266, an English Translation and Explanation. University of British Columbia.