Kidney Sale and the Challenge of Human Dignity: A Comparative Analysis of Quranic and Kantian Approaches

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Assistant Professor, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

A controversial question in medical ethics is whether or not organ sale amounts to a violation of human dignity. To answer the question, we need to analyze various approaches to the problem of human dignity. In this paper, I focus on Islamic-Quranic and Kantian approaches to the problem, and examine the challenge of human dignity concerning kidney sale with a descriptive-analytic method. I show that, on both approaches, kidney sale per se does not compromise human dignity. Rather, it may as well protect human dignity and esteem. The key difference between the two approaches is with respect to conditions to be met in order for kidney sale to accord with human dignity. According to the Quranic account of human dignity, kidney sale will be compatible with human dignity and will thus be morally permissible if it is done for the sake of divine consent or satisfaction. However, on Kant’s view, kidney sale will be permissible when it is done out of respect for the law of reason, without involving any instrumentalization of a human being and his body organs. Other differences between the two approaches consist in the origin of human dignity, instrumental or non-instrumental view of the reason, and the extent of responsibility towards others.

Keywords

References

Akhavan, Mahdi. 1390 Sh. “Keramat-e ensānī dar akhlāq-e Kāntī.” Naqd va naẓar 61:136-67.
Al-Khader, A. A. 2002. “The Iranian Transplant Programme: Comment from an Islamic Perspective.” Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation 17: 213–15.
Bojnurdī, Sayyid Muḥammad. 1401 AH. Qawāʿid fiqhiyya, Tehran: ʿOrūj Institute.
Cameron, J. Stewart, and Raymond Hoffenberg. 1999. “The Ethics of Organ Transplantation Reconsidered: Paid Organ Donation and the Use of Executed Prisoners and Donors.” Kidney International 55 (2): 733-7.
Cohen, C. B. 2002. “Public Policy and the Sale of Human Organs.” Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 12 (1): 47–64.
Dehghan Simakani, Rahim. 2019. “Ethical Challenges of Kidney Sale: A Review of Three Major Assumptions Based on the Theories of Ṭabāṭabā’ī.” Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 61:27-33.
Gill, M., and R. M. Sade. 2002. “Payment for Kidneys: The Case for Repealing Prohibition.” Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 12(1): 17–46.
Hashemī, Sayyed Mohammad. 1384 Sh. Hoqūq-e bashar va āzādī-hāye sīyāsī (Human Rights and Political Freedoms). Tehran: Mizān Publications.
Ja’farī, Mohammad Taqī. 1370 Sh. Hoqūq-e jahānī-ye bashar az dīdgāh-e Eslām va gharb (World Human Rights in the Views of Islam and the West). Tehran: Publications of the Office for International Legal Services of the Islamic Republic of Iran.
Javādī Āmolī, ʿAbdollāh. 1381 Sh. Sūrat va sīrat-e ensān dar Qurʾān (Human Appearance and Practice in the Quran). Edited by Gholām ʿAlī Amīndīn. Qom: Esraʾ.
Kant, Immanuel. 1996. “The Metaphysics of Morals.” In Immanuel Kant: Practical Philosophy, translated and edited by Mary Gregor, 203–506. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kant, Immanuel .1997a. Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, Translated by Mary Gregor, with an introduction by Christine. M. Korsgaard. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kant, Immanuel.1997b. Lectures on Ethics. Edited by Peter Heath, and J. B. Schneewind. Translated by Peter Heath. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kant, Immanuel. 2002a. Critique of Practical Reason. Translated by Werner S. Pluhar, with an introduction by Stephen Engstrom. Indianapolis/Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company, Inc.
Kant, Immanuel. 2002b. Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals. Translated by A. Zweig. Edited by T. E. Hill and A. Zweig. New York: Oxford University Press.
Kant, Immanuel. 2009. Religion within the Bounds of Bare Reason. Translated by Werner S. Pluhar, with an introduction by Stephen R. Palmquist. Indianapolis/Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company, Inc.
Karājakī, Muḥammad b. ʿAlī al-. 1410 AH. Kanz al-fawā’id. Qom: Dār al-Dhakhāʾir.
Kerstein S. J. 2009. “Kantian Condemnation of Commerce in Organs.” Ken­nedy Institute of Ethics Journal 19 (2): 147–69.
Levin, Adeera, et al. 2017. “Global Kidney Health 2017 and Beyond: A Roadmap for Closing Gaps in Care, Research, and Policy.” The Lancet 390 (10105): 1888–917.
Louden, Robert B. 2006. “Applying Kant's Ethics: The Role of Anthropology.” In A Companion to Kant, edited by Graham Bird. Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
Moazam, Farhat, Riffat Moazam Zaman, and Aamir M. Jafarey. 2009. “Conversations with Kidney Vendors in Pakistan: An Ethnographic Study.” Hastings Center Report 39 (3): 29-44.
Motahhari, Mortaza. 1372 Sh. Majmūʿeh athār (Collected Works). Tehran: Sadrā.
Mullā Ṣadrā, Muḥammad b. Ibrāhīm. 1383 Sh. Sharḥ Uṣūl al-Kāfī. Research Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies.
Rachels, James. 2012. The Elements of Moral Philosophy. New York: McGraw-Hill. 
Sensen, Oliver. 2011. Kant on Human Dignity. Berlin/Boston: Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG.
Stempsey, William E. 1996. “Paying People to Give Up Their Organs: The Problem with Commodification of Body Parts.” Medical Humanities Review 10, 45–55.
Stempsey, William E. 2000. “Organ Markets and Human Dignity: On Selling Your Body and Soul.” Christian Bioethics 6 (2): 195–204.
Stratton-Lake, Philip. 2000. Kant, Duty and Moral Worth. London and New York: Routledge.
Sullivan, Roger. J. 1994. An Introduction to Kant's Ethics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ṭabātabāʾī, Muḥammad Ḥusayn. 1370 Sh. Tafsīr al-mīzān. Tehran: Esmāʿīlīyān Institute.
Tamīmī al-Āmidī, ‘Abd al-Wāḥid b. Muḥammad. 1410 AH. Ghurar al-ḥikam wa durar al-kilam. Qom: Dār al-Kitāb al-Islāmī.
The Qurʾan. Translated by Mohammad Hamid Shaker.
Zargooshi, J. 2001. “Quality of Life of Iranian Kidney ‘Donors.’” Journal of Urology 166 (5): 1790–99.
Zümrüt, Alpinar-Şencan, Baumann Holger, and Nikola Biller-Andorno. 2017. “Does Organ Selling Violate Human Dignity?” Monash Bioethics Review 34:189-205.
Religious Inquiries
Volume 10, Issue 20 - Serial Number 20
December 2021
Pages 107-127

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics